When it comes to maintaining a healthy, manicured lawn, a reliable Craftsman self propelled lawn mower can make all the difference. Known for their durability, ease of use, and consistent performance, Craftsman mowers are trusted by homeowners across the country. Whether you’re dealing with a small suburban yard or a larger patch of grass, a self-propelled model reduces physical strain while delivering professional-quality cuts. In this roundup, we’ve tested and reviewed the best Craftsman self propelled lawn mowers and related essentials—from replacement parts to protective covers—to help you find the perfect fit for your lawn care needs.
Quick Product Comparison
Our Top 5 Best Craftsman Self Propelled Lawn Mower Reviews – Expert Tested & Recommended
1. Lawn Mower Cover with PA Coating & Double Drawstring & Storage Bag, Heavy Duty 600D Polyester Oxford Fabric
This heavy-duty lawn mower cover is a must-have for protecting your Craftsman self propelled lawn mower from the elements. Made with 600D polyester Oxford fabric and a waterproof PA coating, it shields against rain, snow, UV rays, and dust. The double drawstring design ensures a snug fit, even in windy conditions.
Key Features That Stand Out
- ✓ Double drawstring bottom for secure, adjustable fit
- ✓ Waterproof PA coating repels moisture and prevents rust
- ✓ 600D polyester Oxford fabric resists tearing and fading
- ✓ Includes a compact storage bag for off-season use
Why We Recommend It
We chose this as our top pick because it offers superior protection without breaking the bank. It’s built to last through harsh winters and scorching summers, keeping your mower in peak condition year-round.
Best For
Homeowners who store their mowers outdoors or in uncovered areas and want long-term protection from weather damage.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Excellent weather resistance
- Easy to install and remove
- Fits most standard walk-behind mowers
- Includes storage bag
Cons:
- May be oversized for very small mowers
- Drawstrings require occasional retying in high winds
Customer Reviews
“Was surprised at the cover quality. I live in a pretty harsh climate – wind and snow in the winter and blistering sun in the summer. Finally got a cover for my trusty Honda mower which I have left uncovered for years. Decided it needs some better protection from the elements. The size worked great.”
“This cover is spectacular. Very easy to use and fits well on the mower, keeping it clean and dry. We have had some pretty windy storms and it stayed in place through them. It has held up really well through many weather events. It is nice and thick without being too bulky or heavy.”
2. CRAFTSMAN CMXGZAM325070 FWD 8-Inch Wheel, Fits Various CRAFTSMAN Walk-Behind Mowers, Snow Blowers
This OEM-quality replacement wheel is designed specifically for Craftsman self propelled lawn mowers with front-wheel drive systems. It delivers smooth operation and reliable traction, making it ideal for restoring older mowers to like-new performance.
Key Features That Stand Out
- ✓ Front wheel drive compatibility for precise power delivery
- ✓ Aggressive tread pattern enhances grip on wet or uneven terrain
- ✓ Bolt-on installation—no special tools required
- ✓ Rigorously tested for safety and durability
Why We Recommend It
As an official Craftsman part, this wheel ensures perfect fit and function. It’s a simple upgrade that can dramatically improve your mower’s performance, especially if your original wheels are worn or slipping.
Best For
Owners of older Craftsman self-propelled mowers needing reliable replacement wheels to restore traction and ease of use.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Exact OEM fit for many Craftsman models
- Improves mower handling and propulsion
- Durable construction resists wear
- Easy to install
Cons:
- Sold individually—may need to order two
- Limited to front-wheel drive models only
Customer Reviews
“This is shipped as a single item. I assumed that the price was for two because who would only replace one wheel at a time? I ordered a second one to complete the wheel upgrade on my Craftsman self propelled FWD mower. The old wheels were really worn down to the point where I had to push the mower.”
“Exact replacements for my grandfather-in-law. Hopefully they last longer than the factory ones.”
3. WEN 20V Max 2-in-1 Cordless Lawn Mower
While not a Craftsman brand mower, the WEN 20V Max offers exceptional value as a budget-friendly alternative to traditional gas-powered models. This lightweight, cordless mower doubles as a mulcher and delivers quiet, emission-free cutting—perfect for small to medium yards.
Key Features That Stand Out
- ✓ Brushless motor increases efficiency and lifespan
- ✓ 2-in-1 design: mowing and mulching in one machine
- ✓ Five height settings from 1.5″ to 3.2″
- ✓ 5.0Ah lithium-ion battery with LED charge indicator
Why We Recommend It
For under $200, this mower delivers surprising power and versatility. It’s eco-friendly, low-maintenance, and easy to maneuver—making it a great entry-level option or backup mower.
Best For
Eco-conscious homeowners with small lawns who want a quiet, affordable, and easy-to-use mower without the hassle of gas or cords.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Lightweight and easy to store
- No gas, oil, or cords required
- Mulching capability reduces yard waste
- Battery compatible with other WEN 20V tools
Cons:
- Limited runtime on a single charge (best for yards under 1/4 acre)
- Not self-propelled—requires manual pushing
Customer Reviews
“Surprisingly fantastic! I ordered this as a backup until my rider parts come in. My grass was long enough the cops stopped by to tell me to cut it! I got just over half my yard done on the first charge but let me say that the bag was STUFFED after just 3 passes across the front of my yard (about 90 feet).”
“Love it. It’s light, batteries recharge as they should, and best of all it cuts the grass. Yay!”
4. MaxPower 331740B Blade for 22 in. Cut Craftsman, Husqvarna, Poulan Mowers
This high-quality replacement blade fits a wide range of 22-inch cut mowers, including many Craftsman self propelled models. Precision-balanced and sharpened, it delivers clean cuts and improved grass health with every pass.
Key Features That Stand Out
- ✓ Replaces multiple OEM numbers (420463, 421825, 532421825, etc.)
- ✓ Fits Craftsman, Husqvarna, and Poulan mowers
- ✓ Heat-treated steel for durability and sharpness retention
- ✓ Pre-balanced for reduced vibration and smoother operation
Why We Recommend It
A dull blade tears grass instead of cutting it, leading to brown tips and disease. This MaxPower blade restores your mower’s cutting performance at a fraction of the cost of OEM parts.
Best For
DIYers looking to maintain their mower’s cutting efficiency without paying premium prices for brand-name blades.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Sharp out of the box—no additional sharpening needed
- Compatible with many popular mower brands
- Affordable upgrade over factory blades
- Easy to install with basic tools
Cons:
- May require checking compatibility before purchase
- Not suitable for mulching kits without modification
Customer Reviews
“Fits perfectly, easy to install, cut is good, blade is durable and functional. Same blade I replaced my original one with—price was very reasonable.”
“Fits perfectly, easy to install, cut is good, blade is durable and functional. Same blade I replaced my original one with—price was very reasonable.”
5. American Lawn Mower Company 1204 14-Inch Reel Mower
This manual reel mower offers a quiet, eco-friendly alternative to gas or electric models. Though not self-propelled, its lightweight design and precision cutting make it ideal for small, flat lawns where sustainability matters.
Key Features That Stand Out
- ✓ 4-blade reel system delivers scissor-like clean cuts
- ✓ Adjustable cutting height from 0.5″ to 1.75″
- ✓ Only 19 pounds—easy to push and store
- ✓ Zero emissions, no fuel, no cords
Why We Recommend It
While not a Craftsman self propelled lawn mower, this reel mower is perfect for eco-minded users with small yards. It promotes healthier grass growth and reduces your carbon footprint.
Best For
Environmentally conscious homeowners with small, flat lawns who prefer a quiet, low-maintenance mowing experience.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Silent operation—great for early morning mowing
- No ongoing fuel or electricity costs
- Promotes healthier, greener grass
- Minimal maintenance required
Cons:
- Not effective on tall or wet grass
- Manual effort required—not suitable for large yards
- Limited cutting height range
Customer Reviews
“I’ve been using a traditional gas rotary mower for years and had heard good things about reel mowers. There’s a lot of options, and I tried out a Scotts 16″ Elite Reel Mower first from a local store before upgrading to this 18-Inch 5-Blade Reel American Lawn Mower, and overall, I am pleased with it.”
“Perfect little rotary mower. I have a strip about 100′ long and 10″ wide that my robot mowers can’t cut because it is too close to the curb. My riding mower can’t cut it low enough without scalping the ground, so this was the perfect solution. I was a little skeptical because one wheel is on the grass…”
Complete Buying Guide for Craftsman Self Propelled Lawn Mowers
Essential Factors We Consider
When evaluating the best Craftsman self propelled lawn mower options, we focus on key performance indicators like engine power, cutting width, drive system reliability, ease of maintenance, and user comfort. Self-propelled models should reduce physical effort without sacrificing control. We also consider compatibility with replacement parts, warranty coverage, and real-world durability based on customer feedback.
Budget Planning
Prices for Craftsman self-propelled mowers typically range from $250 to $500, depending on features like engine size, deck material, and added functions (e.g., bagging, mulching, side discharge). While OEM parts and accessories may cost extra, investing in quality replacements—like wheels or blades—can extend your mower’s life and improve performance. For budget-conscious buyers, alternatives like the WEN cordless mower offer great value without compromising too much on quality.
Final Thoughts
Whether you’re upgrading your current setup or maintaining an older Craftsman model, choosing the right mower—and the right support products—makes all the difference. Prioritize reliability, ease of use, and long-term value. And don’t forget protection: a good cover can save you hundreds in repairs down the road.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Are Craftsman self propelled lawn mowers reliable?
A: Yes, Craftsman mowers are known for their durability and consistent performance. Many models feature robust engines, sturdy steel decks, and reliable front- or rear-wheel drive systems that make mowing easier on slopes and uneven terrain.
Q: Can I use non-Craftsman parts on my Craftsman mower?
A: In many cases, yes—especially for universal components like blades and wheels. However, always verify compatibility using your mower’s model number to ensure proper fit and safe operation.
Q: How often should I replace my mower blade?
A: We recommend inspecting your blade at least once per season. Replace it if it’s bent, cracked, or excessively dull. A sharp blade ensures clean cuts, which promote healthier grass and reduce disease risk.
Q: Do I really need a mower cover?
A: If your mower is stored outside or in a damp garage, absolutely. Moisture, UV exposure, and debris can cause rust, fade paint, and damage internal components. A quality cover like our top pick extends your mower’s lifespan significantly.
Q: What’s the difference between front-wheel and rear-wheel drive?
A: Front-wheel drive is more common and works well on flat to moderately sloped lawns. Rear-wheel drive offers better traction on hills and wet grass, making it ideal for challenging terrain.
Ready to upgrade your lawn care routine? Whether you need a full-featured Craftsman self propelled lawn mower, a durable protective cover, or reliable replacement parts, our top picks offer the best combination of performance, value, and longevity. Click any “Check Price” button above to compare current deals and find the perfect match for your yard!
Related posts:
Is Your Lawn Mower Starter Solenoid Bad How To Tell
How To Adjust a Kohler Engine Carburetor Yourself
6 Best 12 Volt Battery for Lawn Mower: Expert Picks for Reliability
Expert Picks: 7 Best 12V Batteries for Riding Lawn Mowers
8 Top 12 Volt Lawn Mower Batteries: Expert Reviews for Durability
5 Best 16 Inch Hedge Trimmers: Expert Picks for Quality & Precision
6 Best 16 Inch Lawn Mowers
Unbiased Guide: 7 Best 18 Inch Lawn Mowers Reviewed by Experts
9 Best 18V Batteries for Black & Decker Hedge Trimmer: Expert Picks
5 Best 190cc Lawn Mower: Expert Picks for Top Quality
Expert Picks: 6 Best 2 Cycle Lawn Mower Engine Oils for Longevity
7 Best 2-Stage Snow Blowers: Expert Reviews for Top Quality
